This is an old favourite of ours. We revisited Bangkok Garden after maybe...five years of not going. There was really no reason why we stopped; we've always found the food amazing. Tonight, I can definitively say that this is my favourite Thai restaurant in Toronto because of the variety, the authentic taste, and the ambiance. We recently took a trip to Thailand and this restaurant reminded us of a couple of great Bangkok restaurants.
I'm surprised by the 3-star average rating. While I must say that Sukhothai has been my long-standing go-to Thai restaurant, I think one can't really compare Bangkok Garden as it offers a lot of dishes that Sukhothai and the other places do not.
I say give it a chance - go for their regular menu at least once!