I really like this place and am a frequent patron on my regular trips to Pittsburgh. The brews are fresh and the selection is awesome. The food is typically good pub-grub...nothing exotic but hearty and tasty. The decor maintains the beauty of this old church...terrific stained glass work.
Probably an extra half star if the bartenders that worked here were a bit more interactive. The wait staff is pleasant and helpful but the folks behind the bar generally act as though they're doing you a favor drawing a cold one...what's up with that? The space can tend to 'echo' a bit but a nice place to spend an hour or two with friends.