My friends and I would say 4 stars, but if my ass hole had a vote, it would have said negative 5 stars. I ordered online, and there was not a ranking of least spicy to spiciest. Obviously, wimpy was the weakest. But wouldn't one think that Jet Fuel is hotter than afterburner? I can tell you what gets the after burn, and it's your ass hole. I immediately started sweating, and my nose started running. Everyone around me immediately became concerned. And then about 15 minutes later, my stomach also showed me it's concern. All in all, I think Wings Over Madison needs better descriptions on their online ordering system to save one ass hole at a time.