I went to Hamilton's last weekend with some friends. Beautiful atmosphere. Everyone agreed the meat entrees were delicious. Really, I think some of the best in Madison. The appetizers were ok. The desserts were wonderful as well. However my only gripe was the service was not what I expected. We went there for a special dinner, to enjoy a leisurely dinner with friends. However, we got the feeling the waitress wanted to turn over her table as soon as possible. For the amount of money they charge for their food, I expect to enjoy my time there. It will be some time before trying it again. :(