Despite living nearby for over 10 years this is the first time I've been to the Miller Tavern. We went at 6:00pm for dinner and even though they couldn't find our reservation we were seated promptly on the closed-in balcony upstairs. The downstairs was a bit dark but it was nice and bright where we were sitting. It was also roomy and airy on the second floor. The place has a medium sized free private parking lot with a large GreenP lot adjacent to it. The server seemed genuinely concerned with our satisfaction. I was actually impressed by the seafood salad ($23) which was mostly fish, shrimp, and a large crab cake rather than greenery with microscopic pieces of unidentifiable bits. The presentation was delightful and I found the portion size also to be just right. The calamari was also creatively plated and the steak and frites were yummy. I didn't have occasion to scope the bathrooms but the restaurant seemed clean in general. Overall our entire party really enjoyed it and I would go back again!