First time...and I will be back. I'm almost disappointed in myself for seeing this place come up in my Yelp searches before and deciding to go somewhere else. Shame on me for sticking to "what I know." My boyfriend and I have lived right around the corner for the last two years, and have been neglecting this gem. We looked over the menu before we arrived because we knew we'd be standing at the counter, trying to make a decision otherwise. We ordered the combo basket to get a little bit of everything and a cod taco to round out our experience. Everything was perfect. I'm a sucker for seafood but I hate the "fishy" smell/taste or that "over-priced seafood restaurant" experience and you won't find either one of those things here.