I had low expectations because the reviews weren't amazing but I was really pleasantly surprised!!
First of all I have to comment on the service...AMAZING. probably the best service I've had at a restaurant in a long time. Our waitress was extremely attentive but not invasive and never left us without a full drink (in some tiny glasses!) We sat at the pizza bar and some of the chefs behind the bar checked on us as well and were interested as to whether we liked our food. Every person I encountered on the staff was extremely friendly and helpful.
Now the food, we started with the wedding soup which was very tasty and had lots of "stuff" in it, which is great! Next was the mambo pizza and one more (whose name I forget) that had ricotta, Peruvian peppers and sausage. Both were Delicious. The crust was crispy on the outside and slightly charred, and the inside was soft and doughy. The toppings were plentiful and extremely fresh. Half a pie was enough for both of us.
Finished a great meal with a piece of tiramisu, which was delicious and was inhaled so quickly I can't comment on it much more. I thought the "m" on top in powdered sugar was a cute touch.
The atmosphere inside was loud but in an energetic way. Just be wary if you prefer quiet dining because there was definitely not a quiet spot in the place. I liked sitting at the pizza bar because we could watch the chefs work. For two sodas, soup, two pizzas and dessert the bill came to $59.