Food is 5 stars.
We went there with no reservation on a Friday night. We sat at the oyster bar. Ordered oysters for appetizers. (Amazing). Husband ordered the lobster sandwich with fries (unbelievably delicious), and I had the fish tacos, which were some of the best I've EVER had. They fish was not too heavy, lightly bartered and fresh.
For dessert we had the homemade strawberry ice cream and the s'mores. I inhaled most of it :)
Why the 4 stars ? Service was just okay. It was a bit slow and our waiter wasn't very friendly. I Ordered a Diet Coke and he seemed to have forgotten about it but got my husband his Manhattan in no time. Not a big deal - would still recommend.