The four stars are for the breakfast sandwich, which is egg, cheese, and peameal bacon on a bun. This is a solid breakfast sandwich.
If you just get the peameal bacon sandwich, you might be disappointed. The bacon taste good, but they put a lot of slices in it and nothing else. No sauce. You can add mustard for some flavour, but it's pretty dry and boring.
And, it's a bit pricey when you consider it's just dry bacon and bread. So get the breakfast sandwich only.
(note: there's always a line up here on weekends, but a lot of it is people just standing around thinking of what to order or waiting for something they probably shouldn't have ordered. if you're in for the peameal bacon or breakfast sandwich, it's done quickly. So don't let the dumbfounded tourists/locals fool you. Just step right up and place your order).
3.5 stars out of 5.
Jimmy's Yelp Ratings Scale for Food:
[*] Disappointing. Just...no.
[**] Not very good. Will not return.
[***] It is what it is. Go enough times and you'll break even on quality.
[****] My go-to place. Rarely disappoints.
[*****] Everything on menu is good. Every time.