I find myself here at least every few weeks if not more depending on when I get a cheesesteak craving, and when I do, this is the place I HAVE to come to. I have yet to find a better cheesesteak in Newmarket and honestly don't think I'll even bother looking so long as Philty Phillies is around.
My go to order is the regular cheesesteak with double provolone, onions and cheese whiz as well as a bacon cheesesteak poutine. I find even getting regular size servings can generally feed 2 people easily but maybe that's just me. The staff is always pleasant and the quality is fairly consistent.
They also recently introduced a delivery option which will definitely enable me to be even philthier than I already am. My love for this establishment knows no bounds so please do yourself a favor and pay Philty Phillies a visit, I promise you won't regret it.