Tried for a Saturday lunch recently with a Groupon deal. Pizza & salad. First thing I noticed when we walked in was we were the ONLY ones there at lunchtime. And the pizza gal behind the counter looked like she desperately wanted to be somewhere else.
I'm inclined to go overboard with pick-your-own pizza so I decided to try the chef's special shrimp alfredo pizza. Pizza gal reluctantly waited on us with the same level of disinterest - and managed to botch my pizza order (even tho it was their special selection). Mgr came to save the day and pizza gal remade my pizza correctly.
Pizza tasted pretty good, but the thin-crust wasn't great, kind of tough and rather flavorless (and I am a crust lover). Oddly the salad was quite good with a very nice balsamic dressing, far better than expected.
Dine in was good. Décor was done with a good amount of $$ and care. Interesting restrooms with some trendy new hand-dryer thingy I had to figure out. Maybe during the week they are busy? I hope for success here but there is a tremendous amount of competition in this market and Pie5 doesn't stand out for me.