Again, I gotta hype the (good) local shops and this is as local as it gets as it's within biking distance. I started coming into Mario's right after they opened and haven't been disappointed yet. Whether you order a whole pie or by the slice, their pizza kicks ass. Like most pizzerias, they give you more bang for your buck and are usually cheaper than most places that deliver. Every time I've been there, Mario is behind the counter and always greets me. I get the feeling that members of his family work there as well including his wife.
Bottom line: Mario's is my first choice for pizza because of quality, price, location, and the people who run it.