We've been going to Hal's the 3 years we've lived here. Honestly, never had a bad meal. Not even when they are packed because there's a game on. The parking lot can get a little interesting but only because there are next door to a billiard room.
They have a well rounded menu from chicken wings to risotto! Truly my 1 and only dislike is the sausage they use on their pizza. I'm from Chicago and it's not what I consider a pizza sausage, it's more like kielbasa (which might be ok for a Yinzer, but I didn't like it) - other than that their pizza is good and HUGE and in-expensive.
I've met Hal several times as he often delivers the food himself. Great guy and family man. Wide array of liquor to chose from and usually a sports game on TV if you are into that.
Give it a try, I think it will be worth the trip.
Whenever someone new moves to town we take them to Hal's and we haven't heard one complaint yet!