Like a lot of locals, I first came to the Hill after a night of drinking (great hangover food!). I've since stopped drinking, but I still depend on this place for a solid breakfast.
This location has been codenamed "the good one" by Boyfriend and I, so we make the trip on Saturday mornings rather than go to the location right up the street. This location just seems better put together than the others. As a twosome, we are usually seated very quickly. The service is not exceptional, but leaves nothing to be desired. The waitresses are exactly what you'd expect in a diner (after walking in the doors, you have no name. You'll be known as "honey" or "sweetie").
I can honestly say that I've never gotten a non-breakfast item, given that breakfast is awesome and served 24 hours. My guilty pleasure is the eggs benedict. Whether you get actual poached eggs or not is a toss-up, but it's still tasty. Really, I've never been disappointed.
The Hill is a step down from The Cracked Egg in price and taste, but still quite a few steps from the bottom!