I came here for my first time with a friend who's a somewhat regular - I'm glad I joined her!
This place is adorable. The downstairs is cozy and warm - perfect for a night-in when it's chilly outside. We were hungry, so were ordered one of the specials (gyro with a side for $10). It was delicious! One of the best I've ever had (mostly because the pita was just the best.) The server was really nice and attentive and came refreshing our beers as needed.
I would definitely be back!