The only decent deli in town.
Now I'm talking Jewish Deli - for Italian Deli there's always Ginos, Frabonis, etc. But for Jewish Deli, nothing comes close.
I'm from the Detroit Area, where we have a large Jewish population. Great delis.
I've been to NYC many times. Great delis (Carnegie is ok, Katz's is mind blowing).
Madison, not so much.
Living in Madison, a decent deli is something I've missed for a long time. I've tried every suggestion for 'a great reuben' and have been disappointed every time.
That being said, I wasn't super impressed with Stalzys' reuben - not nearly enough meat. What I would suggest is ordering the 'bread meat bread' sandwich. The bread meat bread is the only sandwich* I've had here (or anywhere in Madison) that has enough meat that I would consider it a deli sandwich.
Not a good deli by serious deli standards, but definitely decent. Hands down the best I've had in Madison.
*burgers excluded