Not completely sure I understand all of the five star reviews but this bar sure has potential. We ordered the fish fry which was ok... and expensive. We also got the buffalo chicken salad. Now that was delicious! The margarita I got was very very weak and honestly just tasted like something from a pre mixed bottle.
Now in terms of atmosphere, Hail Mary has that in spades. Pretty sweet to watch sports games in old church. I don't like the high tables as much or the tile floor but the open space and stained glass is just too cool.
I'm sure I'll be back but I may just stick to the buffalo chicken salad.