We got married in May 2009. We rented a tux from Best Bridal and Tuxedo. The staff was great and they had several options for John to pick from. John was fitted and we were able to pick up the tux the next morning.
Needless to say John looked so handsome in his tux, I would highly recommend Best Bridal and Tuxedo for all your formal needs.
One minor detail is location, the bridal shop sits well into a strip mall and is a little hard to find if you are not from the area, otherwise a very positive experience.