This place makes a mean burger. There are a ton to choose from, too. They put all kinds of different sauces on them, which I appreciate as a real sauce-guy. You really can't go wrong, I've been here a few times and had a tasty burger every single time. If you're in Madison and love burgers, you gotta go here.
If you don't love burgers... you may still want to go here. I recently tried the wings and cheese curds - both of which are pretty dang good. The curds have a light batter to them. Not quite Old Fashioned good, but definitely tasty. Also, their chili was excellent and so were the chicken wings. This place can do no wrong!