We have eaten at Afton Tavern on about 5 different occasions and have loved it every time. I always try something new off their extensive menu and have been happy 4 out of the 5 times. My only complaint is with the "Fish & Chips" that is offered.
It is not your typical fish and chips so I was disappointed. I was served a filet-o-fish and this is not what fish and chips is to me. However the fish was crisp and delicious so I was too upset. I've had the burgers, tavern tacos and the chicken & dumplings. All were tasty and would definitely order these items again.
Must try the cookie skillet & oatmeal scotchie for dessert=awesome.