My feelings are mixed, so I'll review each item:
Strawberry cupcake - incredible, sweet cake but the frosting is a bit dense and simple. That cake though.
Smores cupcake - very good. They should used torched marshmallows as frosting more often. See review of strawberry cupcake.
Oatmeal pie - regretting I purchased two. I regret purchasing any, actually. Bland AF. Throw some cinnamon in there! As is, it tastes like cardboard with a Crisco "cream" filling. Ever eat something and think, "this is not worth the calories?" Me either, until I ate their oatmeal pie.
Ricotta cookie - encouraged by the employee to just try one, I did. For $1.75. I wanted to split it with my husband, and took a tiny, supremely disappointing bite.
Rice crispy brownie "bar" - for $3-4 it was a bad deal.
Conclusion: 2.5 stars. The cupcakes are great (there are no quantity discounts which is a turn off) but nothing else is. My search for really solid baked goods wears on.