Good but not great. Like others, I think maybe my expectations were too high. Having eaten at a few awesome grilled cheese spots in Vancouver, it was definitely not the best grilled cheese I have ever had - but was good. I ordered the Hamlet, which was pretty ordinary ham and cheese w/ onions and tomatoes, so maybe it was my ordering that was the problem. The avocado / apple one looks interesting, maybe I will try that next time.
I also ordered a cream of broccoli soup on the side... It was not good. Very watery and had no flavour. Like boiled broccoli in water.
The atmosphere and restaurant decor is awesome... 5 stars for that! Also, it is in a really cool location. Overall, I would recommend you give it a shot but be a bit daring in your order and steer clear of the soups.