We were so excited when Cellar 59 FINALLY opened just 3 blocks from our house! Even better, we can walk there! We were pleasantly surprised to see their great selection of craft beers (including out favorite Left Hand Milk Stout! Yum!). I did try a sweeter wine as recommended by the waitress, and I don't recall being disappointed. We haven't tried any of the food options, but we did think the cheese and meat tray was a bit pricey. I suppose we'll have to try it first before deciding if it's worth the price. Overall, though, if you live in the area, definitely worth a visit!
1/31/14: Just made another visit last night and it was definitely a step in the right direction! I had the sampler flight and really enjoyed trying new wines! The prices seemed to be a bit more reasonable (could be because we recently returned from South Beach where everything was supper pricey...), and everything was really good.