In the last week, my boyfriend has dragged me here three times. We are obsessed. Their spumoni is legit. My boyfriend is from Jersey (where apparently there's spumoni everywhere) and said it's the best he's ever had. He had it for breakfast today. Like a whole pint. For breakfast. We would call ourselves avid ice cream eaters and this place really is the best. Plus the owner, Frederik, is super friendly. They're a little tucked away on 5th Ave, a few doors down from Cartel. Come check it out!
P.S. Those waffle cookies they give you with the gelato are fireeeee.