I ended up here 2x in my week of staying nearby. Both times the servers were excellent (which is why the 4 stars are given). The atmosphere is lovely.
First time was supper time but I wasn't terribly hungry. I got the tomato salad with salmon. Delicious. Tomatoes were perfection. I also tried to order an old fashioned....I'm still not sure what I got but the server was gracious enough to take it back and take it off my bill. My friends loved that they sold wine by the ounce.
Second time was lunch and I ordered a pizza which was disappointing. The crust had zero flavor and seemed to leech the flavors out of the fresh ingredients on top. My friends loved the gnocchi.
Service is top notch. Food ranges from acceptable to really good.