3.5 stars overall. Stayed at Silverton twice. Once in the luxury King and once in a suite. Definitely upgrade to a suite! Don't stay in the lowest rooms here, you'll be disappointed. A jacuzzi tub is awesome after a day of golf or long night sitting at the poker table. The gaming is weak here, though. No poker room. Low stakes games are nice. It's fun to walk around Bass Pro Shops. There are no bros or girls in saran wrapped dresses here. Most people here have kids or are from the Midwest, so no cool factor here. What is nice are the quality of mattress and sheets in your room,$5 Guinness on draft served in glass (not plastic) pint glasses, and a little quiet.
The biggest downside is the shuttle runs infrequently to the strip, so you can rack up cab fares quickly. Could be dangerous driving yourself back and forth to the strip, so you have to plan out your alcohol consumption in advance.
4 stars for quality of hotel, 2 stars for casino and gaming. Silverton needs to offer more shuttle service for me to stay here more often. My go to when there are no deals on the strip.