My steak was cooked to perfection! Gibby's never fails to disappoint. The last time i was there i shared the Oysters Rockefeller which were really tasty. I ordered the filet mignon which was a good size and perfectly medium rare. The service was really good and the decor made me feel like I was in a nice cabin enjoying a great steak with friends. I don't mind paying the price for a meal this good. I left so full really had no room for dessert at all. Yes it was expensive but sometimes its nice to treat yourself. Major plus is this place is in old Montreal, probably one of the nicest parts of the city with a lot of tourists and close to the water.