If you want a real breakfast, then the Come Back cannot be denied. We had a company Christmas party in downtown Madison Saturday night and beelined for the Come Back for breakfast on Sunday morning. The breakfast menu is extensive and most items are cleverly created and satisfyingly greasy. Don't get me wrong, though, this is not a greasy spoon.
My husband and I got the classic eggs benedict. It came with perfectly poached eggs and wonderful Rosemary hollandaise. The fried potatoes were generous. Of course, we partook in the $1 bloody marys. OMG ... really? I couldn't get enough.
The best part of our breakfast was the service. Our waitress was prompt and friendly without hovering. She was always there to fill the coffee.
I can't believe it is so hard to find a good breakfast for under $10, but this is definitely the place to hit. It seems to be a hidden gem among the urban crowd, but everyone is welcome at the Come Back In. Apart from Mickey's, this is the only other breakfast place I will visit in Madison.
Don't let any of the bad reviews sway your enjoyment. This place is a must try. See it yourself. I don't think you will be disappointed.