My husband would give this 5+ if he were writing the review. Maybe it is because I am less of a meat person, but 4 seems right to me. They almost always have a line out the door, but it moves fast. The meats are very good. I like the brisket and husband likes the ribs. The sides are really good. I love the mac n cheese and baked beans. I had the root beer float for the first time and it was SOOOO good. Best root beer float I've ever had.