This place was definitely a dive and a half -- seat cushions were torn up, bathroom was cramped and old, the atmosphere dripped with dinginess -- but if you're cool with all of that, it's a great place. They had a decent beer selection including all of the typical domestics and several craft beers. While I didn't eat there, someone at the table next to me ordered a platter of pierogis that looked and smelled awesome. I was there in the later afternoon on a Saturday and was surprised about just how packed it was in there. People were literally lined up and waiting to to get a seat and standing room was almost non-existent by that point as well. It was extremely loud in there so this isn't a great place for a quiet, intimate conversation, but if you'd like to shout at someone for several hours one evening, Hemingway's is your place! Seems like a place with a high potential for fun, hijinx and revelry!