I am a huge fan of Blue Star Diner. My partner and I went there originally because Dairy Lane had a ridiculously long line, and they have basically the same menu for breakfast.
While breakfast is good, I think their dinner menu is even better. As a pescatarian, I really value places that cater to both my vegetarian and fish-eating appetites, and Blue Star is exceptional at helping a gal out. In particular, I would recommend the tacos for supper. Just remember though, they don't serve tacos until after 4:30 pm. So don't be expecting to have tacos for lunch.
As far as breakfast is concerned, I recommend the stuffed french toast with the berry compote. It has the perfect balance of tangy and sweet.