You cannot go wrong with Smallman Galley. There is literally something for everyone. The Bahnmilicious place was good. I really liked their bone broth. The only dish I've tried from Colonia so far is the churros, but they did not disappoint! But, if you're a first timer I highly recommend a Detroit style pizza from Iron Born and the AMAZING yet simple deconstructed s'mores dessert from Brunois. Add in a small, but impressive draft list and you have an awesome and unique dining experience in the heart of Pittsburgh.