Exactly how I would expect old town to do a cigar bar. Average, uneducated service. Average humidor. Scotch selection is ok and the prices aren't bad. If you like the vibe of typical old town you'll love it here. Personally I prefer a little more classic type ambiance.
Update: completely changed my mind on this place as I go here once a week for the past few months. Despite my initial impression I came back and service was significantly improved. Service has been outstanding and friendly since, the cigar prices are some of the best in the city and this has become one of my favorite stops every Sunday. First impressions and my initial reaction were wrong.