I have to say that 3 stars is the absolute best rating this place can get. I have only eaten here and did not participate in the club thing. I must start by saying that my husband loves this place. Loves it and the first place he wants to go is here to have dinner. Not to mention he loves rum.
The place is really dark and cramped. Apparently the first time we ate here I was really drunk and I told a table of bachlorette party goers that they shouldn't celebrate because she was just going to get fat anyway. I don't remember this.
They also serve a lot of red meat and I cant eat red meat after 5:00pm anymore. We did not eat here the last time we came. My husband loves it so I will probably be going back.