I had to knock them down a star. My first visit was wonderful and what I bought was wonderful. Since then .. well, here are some things you need to be wary of.
1) The dude (owner?) is super nice and friendly. He's engaging and loves the store.
... the ladies ... they're so apathetic and the granny is at times really rude as if she doesn't want you to buy anything because it's too much of a chore.
2) The Strawberry Colazza is wonderful. It's fresh and tasty.
...now everything else in their stock I'd give it a miss or at least don't blame me. I went last time with my wife and we picked up a Strawberry Colazza but for the road we got a small creme cake and a parfait-type thing ... both were stale as wood. One bite and I knew this has been sitting there for at least a few weeks. I think they get the most turnaround with the Strawberry Colazza .. so stick with that
3) This place has weird hours. I've come at least twice finding it closed. Check the hours before you go is all I'm saying.