I came to this restaurant as the ratings here on Yelp were so high! However, I was very disappointed by my experience. Coming here on a Tuesday night, it was quiet, with only two other tables. The decor was nice and cozy. The service was great. What was terrible though, was the food! The risotto I had for appetizer was incredibly salty, the fish for my main was greasy to the point that oil was dripping and my cheese platter at the end featured a very disappointing selection - and this is coming from who LOVES cheese! I didn't finish my main or my cheese platter.
Needless to say, i am surprised by the amazing 4.5 overall rating for Il Mulino. I came here expecting an amazing meal. I had a groupon, but even then, it was not worth the price - we ended up paying an extra $60 in tax (+ 2 glasses of wine) on top of the groupon price. There are far too many other places with better food for a similar price. I feel like the promotional groupon of this restaurant duped a lot of people into thinking the food is good - there was no way that the food in the quality that was served to me, could've garnered such high ratings.