I like Amelie's. I will take any out-of-town visitor there just for the experience and a look-see at some of Charlotte's most bizarre interior design ever. Great place for people watching and gathering with a group. I definitely don't understand the cult-like following this place seems to have gathered, though.
Incredible selection of pastries and all things sweet. But it's almost too much for someone like me- I tend to stick to croissants and baguettes with yummy toppings and cheeses rather than tarts with glazes or macaroons the size of cheeseburgers.
I think my main thing with Amelie's is that it is sensory overload on every level possible and I'm just not that kind of customer. But will I keep returning? Definitely. Nothing else like it. And besides- once you've tasted the caramel salted brownie you're basically hooked for life, even if you never order one again. The very idea keeps luring you back....