I love that you can choose two flavors for a small!
Peppermint patty was very tasty and I love the dark chocolate peppermint combo. Too bad it didn't have little York patties mixed in.
The Grasshopper was also very good, and is basically mint chip with crushed Oreos mixed in. It's definitely the sweeter of the two.
The waffle cone chip was a tad stale and very unimpressive.
With only two workers for the night crowd, I didn't feel like it was prudent (now was I encouraged) to ask for any flavor samples.
Like most gelato places, it's a little pricey for what you get. A "just right" small was $3.60 ($3.89 after tax).
I'd definitely come back if I was in the neighborhood though!