Easily the tastiest pizza in the city (though it is technically tomato pie, not pizza), Salvatore's elevates the eat-in experience with a few things that are elusive in Madison: excellent service & perfect tacos. Have tried pretty much everything on the menu. All is good & some items are spectacular. We love the carnitas tacos, & the carne asada tacos; the Forza pie is flawless; the antipasti is all gorgeous, fresh, & chockful of local veggies. Don't forget to get dessert- it is constantly changing and consistently scrumptious. Salvatore's is a special place, and the Sun Prairie location is also worth the trip for some of their unique pies, but it is also not a super splurge, and part of its appeal is the laidback and genuinely friendly attitude of everyone who works there. As my boyfriend said raptly this morning "I would literally eat Salvatore's every night."