For $60 per person for their dinner buffet, I would choose a mid to top-notch non-buffet restaurant.
This restaurant it good for anyone who loves crab legs, and carved meat (e.g. prime rib), and if you can eat a lot of gelato in one sitting.
Otherwise, yes, they have a lot of different types of cuisine and food options, but each individual food item was quite mediocre. The gelato station was the highlight for me.