I would actually give The Porch 4 1/2 stars. We had a great meal with one of the best waiters (Charles) ever! Charles was very friendly & outgoing, without being over the top. It is rare to have a server who possesses a great sense of humor (warning me that my coffee was close to the temperature of the sun!). Two in our group had the filets ordered/prepared at opposite ends of wellness & we were both impressed! I really enjoyed the Tiramisu - one of the best I've had! My only complaint is an in-house confusion about the call-ahead policy, or at least the miscommunication to our group. Regardless, I'm looking forward to the new location in the South Hills!