The most outstanding thing about this place is the feel. When it first opened, it was too well lit, and had antiseptic tables. Since then it has begun to capitalize more on its clerical provenance--dimming the lights and making it a bit mysterious. This is very much a fun/interesting place to eat. I think that the food is decent, and the beer very reasonable in quality. Ultimately though people come here for the overall experience. We had some friends from Chicago come here to visit who were very Catholic, they had a great time eating there (although they felt like they needed to go to a confessional).