Nothing fancy, but great pizza!
This was my husband's and my favorite pizza place throughout college and med school. There are no frills, just honest to goodness down to earth pizza. We have always loved their thin crust pizza with mushrooms and pepperoni. The crust is thin and crusty, and the tomato sauce very good (and my husband is VERY particular about tomato sauce). Their stuffed crust pizza is even better!
We probably haven't had it for about five year since we now live outside of Madison, but I picked up a pie on my way home last week, and it was JUST as good as we remembered it :)