Don't listen to the haters - this place is great! The owner is super-friendly, always takes good care of me and my wife, and the food is fantastic. I always have the lamb shawarma, as it's so good I can never seem to try anything else. I should force myself (but I know I'll regret not getting it even once!) so I can speak more broadly about the menu. The hummus is super-creamy and flavorful. the meat is always moist and tender, fresh off the rotating meat thingy, and even the salad is a nice, tangy counterpoint to the other flavors on the plate.
We tend to go here mid-afternoon, which is probably a lot more relaxed than a typical college lunch-hour would be. The food is worth lingering over. Recommend highly!