Us & a random lady both walk in at the same time. The woman worker asks whom she can help and we both say, this is the first time I'm here, I am from out of state. Turns out she too was from Michigan and lived not too far away from us. Random start of a review reliving a random Michigander-in-Indiana moment - you are welcome!
Cutting to the chase, Jack Frost is the shiznit. I don't even really like donuts but these puppies are something else! Stick to the simple ones, sometimes simple really is better. The salted caramel was good, albeit it sticky, near impossible to eat and overly sweet. My favorite donut out of the many (specialty) ones we ordered was the cherry cake donut, it tasted like delicious marachino cherries. This is ironic, considering I don't like the actual cherries but I love stuff that is flavored like/with them. My husband too liked his somewhat plain old-fashioned donut.
Either way, all of them were good in their own right and with a selection like theirs you will find your own favorite soon enough. The journey to find that special one, well - that is the fun part!