Hmm. I'd give 3 stars for the room itself. Considering the clientele they're trying to attract, as well as the prices charged, I'm surprised this place is so highly rated by travel magazines. The room itself was spacious & the bed was comfy, but my room had a number of bush-league problems. Nothing super-wrong, but just off overall...for instance:
1. The hot & cold water levers for the sink were reversed. Hot water came out when I turned the lever on the right, and cold water was on the left.
2. The shower handle that controls hot/cold water turned to the right. The diagram on the piece that attaches to the wall says to turn it to the left. The contractor that did the bathroom must have been high when he was installing this stuff.
3. Powdered creamer for the coffee. You spend the money on a Keurig and offer Mighty Leaf teas, but you only have junky non-dairy creamer? The fridge should have half-and-half stocked. I get better creamer at McDonald's.
4. I could hear EVERY footstep of the person upstairs. You know how you can tell if someone is walking on the floor above you, and they sound heavy? This person wasn't an offensive lineman. I felt like I was back in my college apartment. My friend said her neighbor snored so loud it woke her up at 3am, and every hour after that. C'mon, invest in some soundproofing.
The food & service are fantastic, which is why I gave this place 4 stars.