Cibo was okay, it's one of those places I will never choose to go back to myself but if a friend told me she made reservations there I wouldn't complain either.
I thought it was a bit overpriced for what you get. We ordered appetizers that were super tiny even though our waitress said we could easily share between 4. They weren't even that good. The decor is really nice, that is what drew me to go in the first place.
As some people pointed out the staff was friendly to the point of awkwardness. Our waitress interrupted our conversation quite a few times and went on to talk about Cibo's whole history without us asking. I was getting together with friends that I hadn't seen in a while and it was a little irritating having our waitress stand around and talk with us for a while when we were trying to catch up.
The biggest issue I had was they had run out of pizza dough so the only thing we wanted to eat from the menu was a no-go. It was disorganized but maybe they have changed since I first went (it was within the first week they opened). Still, I probably won't go back since the food was "meh" and the service was even more so.