3.5 stars. My husband and I were really hoping to like this place but it fell short for us. Let's get to it...
Pros
1) the history of the place makes it interesting and unique.
2) nice big bar area
3) enjoyed our booth seating to enjoy the piano but also able to sit next to each other
4) open 24 hours
Cons
1) dirty martinis very inconsistent
2) value - 3 small shrimp scampi app not prawns for $15. $5 for each shrimp.
3) mushroom app the sizes of the mushrooms inconsistent
4) location for us
In the middle
1) baked penne good but missing something maybe more seasoning or ricotta cheese
2) lasagna good not the best but not the worst again missing something
Overall decent experience but prob won't go back due to far away and our favorite Italian mastronis is within 2 miles to our home. Recommend to give it a try and judge for yourself.