My wife and I have been going to this place since it was Our Gang Cafe. They have fairly average, but always tasty food, and the service has always been great. We love the patio for a nice relaxing evening.
The one negative is their very non-Italian desert menu. What Italian place doesn't serve canolis? They also don't serve cappuccino or espresso so plan on going elsewhere for desert.
The lounge next door is apparently under the same ownership, and is a great place to enjoy a glass of wine and some anti pasta before dinner.