I feel in love with place when I was in college. If you are caving seafood this is the place to go. Every time my family come up for a visit they request Pier 51. They have great lunch special that will not break your wallet. They just added an all you can eat buffet to their lunch menu.
The staff is always friendly and even the cooks comes out and makes sure you enjoyed your meal. You should check them out if you haven't.